Your Offer Was Accepted, but the Preliminary Contract Has New Terms: Must You Sign?

Your offer to buy an Italian property has been accepted. A week later, the agent sends a longer contratto preliminare—the compromesso—and asks you to sign. It adds a larger deposit, removes a condition or changes the date by which the seller must deliver the property.

You do not have to accept new terms merely because your offer was accepted. But you must not assume that declining the new draft cancels the agreement you may already have made. The first question is what the accepted offer legally established. The second is whether the proposed preliminary records that agreement or tries to change it.

Do not compare the new draft with what the agent remembers agreeing. Compare it, line by line, with the accepted offer.

Short answer: must you sign the new preliminary?

Not automatically. Whether you must sign a later document, and on what terms, depends on the wording and legal effect of the accepted offer.

An accepted offer containing the essential terms may already create a binding preliminary agreement. If so, the other party cannot impose different terms unilaterally. Equally, refusing to sign any further document may not free you from obligations under the agreement already made.

Some offers expressly anticipate a later preliminary and leave particular matters for further agreement. Those documents need a closer reading: the fact that they mention a future compromesso neither makes the first document automatically non-binding nor proves that every term in a later draft was already agreed.

First establish what was accepted

Obtain the complete signed file before discussing the new draft:

  • Your offer, including every attachment and amendment.
  • The seller’s signed acceptance.
  • Evidence of when and how acceptance was communicated to you.
  • Any counteroffer, email or written agreement made afterwards.
  • The proposed preliminary contract and its attachments.
  • The payment instructions and any receipt for money already paid.

Check especially whether the seller accepted your offer as written. A response that changes a term may be a counterproposal rather than an acceptance of the original offer. Do not rely on an agent’s message that “the deal is done” without reading the signed documents.

For the separate question of whether an offer can be withdrawn, read Can You Withdraw an Offer to Buy Property in Italy?.

Compare the two texts

Some differences simply add detail. Others move risk from the seller to you. Make a comparison before signing, even if the new draft is described as “standard”.

TermAccepted offerNew preliminaryQuestion to resolve
Property includedHouse, garage and landHouse and land onlyWas the garage intentionally removed?
Deposit€20,000 under stated conditions€60,000 payable immediatelyWas the increase agreed, and what protects it?
MortgagePurchase conditional on approvalCondition absentWhy would the buyer give up this protection?
DocumentsSeller to provide building fileNo delivery obligationWhat happens if records are missing?
Existing worksSeller to resolve a specified issueBuyer accepts property “as is”Who now bears the risk?
CompletionDate linked to document deliveryFixed earlier dateCan the buyer complete safely in time?
PossessionVacant at the deedSeller remains for several weeksWas delayed handover agreed?

Do not sign on the understanding that an unfavourable change “will not matter in practice”. The signed text is what will matter if the transaction becomes disputed.

Which additions deserve the closest attention?

A longer preliminary can properly deal with matters omitted from a short offer. It can also insert obligations you never agreed to. Pay particular attention to:

  • The deposit: an increased amount, earlier payment or change from acconto to caparra confirmatoria alters your exposure.
  • Conditions: a mortgage, document-review or planning condition may disappear or acquire a deadline too short to use.
  • Seller promises: an obligation to discharge a mortgage or resolve an irregularity may become a weaker promise to “cooperate”.
  • Warranties and waivers: broad “as is” wording may sit uneasily with specific promises in the offer.
  • Dates: advancing the deed can leave too little time for finance, technical checks or a power of attorney.
  • Possession: completion and delivery of a vacant home may become two different dates.
  • What is being sold: parking, land, furnishings or an annex may be re-described or excluded.

For the legal consequences of changing the payment’s nature, read Caparra, Deposit or Advance Payment When Buying Property in Italy?.

“It is only a formal document”: should you rely on that?

No. A later preliminary may be longer because it records necessary detail. But if it changes the bargain, signing it can make the new wording part of the parties’ agreement. A reassuring email from the agent is not a substitute for correcting the contract.

Ask for a marked-up copy showing every change from the accepted offer. Where a change is necessary—for example, because due diligence revealed a problem—negotiate it expressly. If it is not agreed, do not sign merely to keep the timetable moving.

What if the seller refuses to remove a new term?

Separate refusing the change from walking away from the purchase. They are not necessarily the same thing.

If an accepted offer already binds both parties on the original terms, you may be able to insist that the next document reflect those terms. But whether either party is obliged to sign a particular further document, and what happens if they refuse, must be assessed from the first agreement’s wording. Avoid an email saying “I am cancelling the deal” before that assessment: it may be read as a refusal to perform an existing obligation.

A safer immediate response is to identify the disputed clauses in writing, state that they do not reflect what you agreed, and ask for a corrected draft while preserving your position. Have your lawyer review the original agreement before setting a deadline or alleging breach.

What if you have already paid a deposit?

The payment does not become refundable just because you dislike the new draft. Nor does the seller automatically become entitled to keep it because you refuse new terms. Both propositions depend on the agreement already made, the payment clause and why the later document has not been signed.

Establish where the money is held, what it was called when paid and whether the accepted offer sets conditions for its release or return. Do not make a further payment under the changed draft until those questions are resolved.

A practical example

A British couple’s accepted offer for an apartment in Rome includes a €25,000 payment and makes the purchase conditional on a satisfactory review of condominium works already approved. The agent’s preliminary arrives two weeks later. It requires another €50,000 immediately and states that the buyers accept all condominium costs, including works approved before the sale.

The buyers do not sign or send the additional money. Their lawyer compares the two documents and marks the changed allocation of costs and missing review condition. The seller agrees to restore the original protection and supply the condominium minutes. Only then do the parties settle the expanded preliminary.

The issue was not whether the couple wanted to buy. It was whether they would accept a different risk from the one in their accepted offer.

What to do now

  1. Collect the offer, acceptance, attachments, payment evidence and new preliminary.
  2. Check whether the seller’s response matched the offer or changed it.
  3. Mark every change between the accepted terms and the new draft.
  4. Identify the payment and deadline that will arise next.
  5. Do not sign, pay more or declare the deal cancelled before the documents have been reviewed.
  6. Respond in writing to disputed changes and request a corrected draft.
  7. If the seller will not agree, obtain advice on the obligations and remedies arising from the first document.

For the different question of whether to register or transcribe a preliminary agreement, read Preliminary Contract in Italy: Registration, Transcription and Protection Against Third Parties.

How Govoni Law helps

Govoni Law acts for foreign buyers throughout Italy. We can compare the accepted offer with the proposed preliminary, identify new obligations and missing protections, and propose written revisions before you sign or pay more.

If you have only a deadline and need initial orientation, the Before You Sign Brief can identify the immediate issue; it is not a full comparison and redraft of both contracts. A substantive review of this defined contract problem may fit Light Due Diligence. Where wider title, planning or property checks are also needed, the scope may require Full Legal Due Diligence.

Frequently asked questions

Is an accepted Italian property offer already binding?
It can be. Its effect depends on its terms, the seller’s response and how acceptance was communicated. Do not assume that only the later compromesso matters.

Can the seller add terms to the preliminary after accepting my offer?
The seller can propose them. You do not have to accept changes merely because they appear in a new draft. The original agreement’s effect must still be assessed.

Can I refuse the new preliminary and get my deposit back?
Not automatically. Refusing new terms and ending an existing agreement are different matters. The answer depends on the signed documents and payment clause.

What if the seller changed my offer when signing it?
A response that changes the offer may amount to a counterproposal rather than acceptance of your original terms. Check whether and how you accepted that change.

Should I sign and resolve the differences before the deed?
No. Signing may make the changed terms binding. Resolve material differences in writing first.


If your offer has been accepted but the preliminary contract says something different, contact Govoni Law before signing or paying more. Send both versions, the acceptance and any payment evidence. The decision starts with what you actually agreed, not with the label on the new document.