The Difference Can Decide What You Lose or Recover
Before you pay any money for an Italian property, you need to know what that payment is called in the contract, what it does legally and what happens if the sale does not complete.
A seller or estate agent may ask you to pay a “deposit” shortly after you make an offer on a property in Italy.
For a foreign buyer, the word sounds harmless.
It is not.
In Italian property transactions, a payment may be described in English as a “deposit”, while the Italian contract uses terms such as:
- caparra confirmatoria;
- acconto prezzo;
- deposito;
- somma a titolo di prenotazione;
- caparra penitenziale;
- payment held by an agent;
- payment held under a notarial escrow arrangement.
These are not interchangeable.
The difference may determine whether you simply recover the amount you paid, whether you can claim double the amount, whether the other party may keep the money, and what registration tax applies to the preliminary agreement.
The right question is not:
“How much deposit do I need to pay?”
It is:
What is this payment in law, who controls it, and what happens to it if the transaction does not complete?
The short answer
A caparra confirmatoria is a sum specifically governed by Article 1385 of the Italian Civil Code.
If the party who paid it defaults, the other party may withdraw and retain it.
If the party who received it defaults, the paying party may withdraw and demand double the caparra.
An acconto prezzo is an advance payment against the purchase price. It does not automatically trigger the “loss of the payment / double repayment” mechanism.
A generic English “deposit” does not tell you which legal regime applies. The Italian wording of the signed document, the payment clause and the overall contractual structure do.
What is a caparra confirmatoria?
A caparra confirmatoria is a contractual payment regulated by Article 1385 of the Italian Civil Code.
When the transaction completes, the caparra is returned or credited against the amount due under the agreement, normally the purchase price.
If there is a qualifying contractual default, the innocent party may use the specific withdrawal remedy provided by Article 1385.
If the buyer defaults
If the buyer paid a properly agreed caparra confirmatoria and is in default, the seller may withdraw from the contract and retain the caparra.
Example:
- You sign a preliminary agreement.
- You pay €50,000 as a caparra confirmatoria.
- You later refuse to complete without a valid contractual or legal justification.
- The seller may withdraw and retain the €50,000.
If the seller defaults
If the seller received the caparra confirmatoria and is in default, the buyer may withdraw from the contract and demand double the caparra.
Example:
- You pay €50,000 as a caparra confirmatoria.
- The seller later refuses to complete or cannot perform in circumstances amounting to a relevant default.
- You may withdraw from the contract and demand €100,000.
That is the point foreign buyers often miss:
A true caparra confirmatoria can produce a “double repayment” remedy when the defaulting party is the person who received it.
Article 1385 also allows the innocent party, in appropriate circumstances, to pursue ordinary remedies rather than exercise the caparra withdrawal mechanism — for example, seeking performance of the agreement or termination and damages. These remedies are not simply cumulative: the correct route depends on the facts, the contract, the seriousness of the breach and the buyer’s objective.
What is an acconto prezzo?
An acconto prezzo is an advance against the agreed purchase price.
If the transaction completes, it is credited against the final price.
But it is not a caparra confirmatoria merely because it has been paid before closing.
If the transaction fails, an acconto does not automatically produce the specific Article 1385 result:
- The seller does not automatically have the right to retain it under the caparra rule.
- The buyer does not automatically have the right to demand double.
Instead, the consequences depend on the contract, the reason for non-completion, the contractual remedies and the ordinary rules on breach, restitution, termination and damages.
This is why a buyer should never assume that every advance payment is protected by the “double caparra” rule.
What does “deposit” mean?
In an English-language exchange, “deposit” is often used for any money paid before completion.
In Italian law, that is not precise enough.
A “deposit” may be:
| What the parties call it | What it may actually be | Automatic double repayment if seller defaults? |
|---|---|---|
| Deposit | Caparra confirmatoria | Yes, if it is correctly agreed as such and the buyer elects the Article 1385 withdrawal remedy |
| Deposit | Acconto prezzo | No |
| Reservation deposit | Reservation payment under an agency or seller form | Only if the written agreement expressly and validly provides for it |
| Deposit held by agent | Payment route, not a legal classification | Depends on the underlying contract |
| Escrow deposit | Funds held pending specified conditions | Depends on the escrow and purchase terms; release/return follows agreed conditions |
The title of the payment is not enough. The clause must state what the payment is, whether it is credited against the price, whether it is a caparra confirmatoria, what happens upon default and what happens if agreed conditions are not fulfilled.
The tax difference: 0.50% and the former 3% rule
This is an area where outdated online articles can be misleading.
Historically, where a preliminary contract was not subject to VAT, the registration tax was commonly calculated as:
- €200 fixed registration tax for the preliminary agreement;
- 0.50% on amounts paid as caparra confirmatoria;
- 3% on advance payments (acconti prezzo) not subject to VAT.
That was the traditional distinction many articles still repeat.
However, the current regime for preliminary contracts not subject to VAT provides an 0.50% registration tax for both:
- caparra confirmatoria; and
- acconti prezzo not subject to VAT,
subject to the statutory rule that the amount should not exceed the tax applicable to the final contract. The registration tax paid on the preliminary agreement is generally credited against the taxes due at the final deed, according to the applicable rules.
Where the transaction is subject to VAT, the analysis is different. In broad terms:
- an acconto prezzo may be subject to VAT because it is an advance payment of the price;
- a caparra confirmatoria is not automatically treated as a payment of the price for VAT purposes;
- registration treatment must be checked against the actual contractual structure and the seller’s VAT position.
Therefore, do not decide whether to label a payment “caparra” or “acconto” simply to pursue a perceived tax saving. The legal consequences, the contractual protections and the seller’s tax regime must all be assessed together.
A caparra is not automatically safe
The double-caparra mechanism is valuable, but it does not replace proper legal protection.
A buyer can still face problems if:
- the seller has already received the money directly;
- the seller later disputes that it was in default;
- the clause does not identify the payment correctly;
- the buyer has signed without conditions allowing time for legal due diligence;
- title, planning, cadastral or land issues emerge after the money has been transferred;
- the seller lacks the funds or assets to repay the double caparra;
- the document was drafted by an estate agent and does not address the actual risk of the transaction.
Having a right to claim double is not the same as having the money safely available.
The best protection is not a remedy after the problem. It is a payment structure designed to prevent the problem from becoming expensive.
Why escrow or protected holding may matter
For a high-value purchase, direct payment to the seller is not always the safest route while key conditions remain unresolved.
Where appropriate and practically available, funds may be held through a notarial escrow arrangement or another protected payment structure. The money is released only when specific written conditions have been met.
These may include:
- completion of agreed legal due diligence;
- production of required title, planning or cadastral documents;
- removal or cancellation of a mortgage or other encumbrance;
- confirmation that a material defect has been regularised;
- satisfaction or waiver of a mortgage-finance condition;
- valid execution of the preliminary agreement or final deed;
- another clearly defined contractual milestone.
Escrow does not remove the need for a carefully drafted payment clause. It makes the clause operational by preventing funds from being irreversibly released before the agreed conditions have been satisfied.
The risk in standard agency forms
An estate agent may ask a buyer to sign an offer quickly and to deliver a cheque or transfer a sum described simply as a “deposit”.
That form may be adequate for the agent’s process. It may not be adequate for your risk.
Before you sign, the document should make clear:
- whether the amount is a caparra confirmatoria or an acconto prezzo;
- whether it becomes a caparra only upon acceptance of the offer;
- who will hold the money and when it will be released;
- whether the offer is conditional upon satisfactory legal due diligence;
- what documents the seller must provide;
- what happens if the seller fails to produce documents or regularise a material issue;
- whether you may withdraw without loss if agreed conditions are not met;
- whether the funds can remain protected pending those conditions;
- how the preliminary contract and any paid amounts will be registered.
A verbal assurance that “the deposit is refundable” is not a substitute for a written contractual condition.
Before you pay: ten questions
Before transferring any money, ask:
- Is this payment expressly defined as a caparra confirmatoria, an acconto prezzo or a reservation payment?
- Does the contract state what happens if the buyer defaults?
- Does it state what happens if the seller defaults?
- If it is a caparra confirmatoria, is the Article 1385 mechanism expressly and correctly reflected?
- Is the payment credited against the price if the transaction completes?
- Who will receive and hold the money?
- Can the money be held in a protected arrangement while legal checks are pending?
- Is the offer conditional upon satisfactory legal and, where necessary, technical due diligence?
- Has the seller provided the documents required to understand the actual legal position of the property?
- Has an Italian property lawyer reviewed the document before you sign or transfer funds?
The practical rule
A caparra confirmatoria may give you a powerful remedy: if the seller defaults, you may withdraw and claim double the amount paid.
An acconto prezzo does not automatically do that.
But neither label is enough on its own.
Before you sign or transfer money, the payment must be assessed together with the property documents, the stage of the transaction, the proposed conditions, the identity of the person receiving the money and the available protections if the sale does not proceed.
Do not send money because the document calls it a “deposit”. Send money only once you understand what it means, what protects it and what happens if the transaction fails.
Need a legal review before paying?
If you have received a purchase proposal, reservation agreement, preliminary contract or request for a deposit, send us:
- The property listing;
- The draft offer, reservation document or preliminary agreement;
- The proposed payment amount and deadline;
- The available property documents;
- A short explanation of the stage of the negotiation.
Govoni Law assists international buyers purchasing property in Sardinia and throughout Italy. We review payment clauses, property documents and proposed contractual protections before buyers sign or transfer money.
Choose the level of legal protection that matches the property, the risk and the money at stake: a Before You Sign Brief, a Light Due Diligence or a Full Legal Due Diligence.
Where funds need to be protected pending agreed conditions, read more about our Escrow & Funds Security assistance.
You may also find these guides useful: The Agent Wants You to Sign Today: What to Do Before Making an Offer on Property in Italy and Can You Withdraw an Offer to Buy Property in Italy?
Clear advice in writing. Calls when it matters.