When a seller says “we will regularise it before the deed”, the buyer is being asked to accept a future result in exchange for a present commitment. Before you sign an offer or pay a deposit, you should know exactly what will be regularised, how completion will be proved, by when, and what happens to your money if it does not happen.
This situation is common in Italy. A veranda was enclosed without authorisation. A cadastral plan no longer matches the layout. A pool or annex has an incomplete planning file. An old amnesty application has never been closed. The seller acknowledges the issue and promises to fix it before the notary.
The promise may be sincere and the problem may be solvable. But a promise is not a regularisation. Until the result exists, it is a risk, and the contract decides who carries it.
The seller controls the regularisation. The contract should control the consequences.
If a seller has promised to regularise a property you want to buy, send us the listing, the documents and the draft offer before you commit.
Short answer: should you sign if the seller promises to regularise?
You can, but only if the contract turns the promise into a defined obligation with a clear result, a deadline, documentary proof and a remedy that protects your deposit if the result is not achieved.
A safe structure usually identifies precisely which irregularity will be addressed, which procedure will be used, which document will prove completion, who pays the costs and any sanctions, when the process must be finished, and what the buyer can do if it fails or is delayed. Without those elements, the buyer is relying on goodwill.
Before you sign: when the promise is not enough
| What you are told | Why it is not enough | What the contract should say |
|---|---|---|
| “It will be sorted before the deed” | No defined result or deadline | The exact irregularity, the procedure and a completion date |
| “It is a minor issue” | Minor issues can still block or delay the deed | A description of the issue and the required outcome |
| “The surveyor is handling it” | The buyer has no control over timing or quality | Delivery of the final documents before completion |
| “The amnesty application is almost done” | A pending application is not a granted one | Completion conditional on the grant, with a longstop date |
| “We can adjust the price if needed” | The adjustment is undefined | A price mechanism or retention linked to the outcome |
| “The notary will check it” | The notary checks the deed, not whether your plans are secure | Conditions and evidence agreed before the deed |
| “Pay the deposit now and we will start” | Your money is exposed before any result exists | Deposit terms that are refundable if the condition fails |
A promise is not a completed regularisation
Italian planning irregularities can be addressed in different ways, depending on their nature, their age, the location of the property and the rules in force. Some are corrected by updating the cadastral records. Some require a late compliance application to the municipality. Some require works to remove or modify what was built. Some depend on an old amnesty file being closed. Some cannot be regularised at all.
Recent reforms have introduced simplified routes for certain minor discrepancies and construction tolerances, but whether they apply depends on the specific case. A buyer should not assume that any issue can be fixed simply because the seller says so.
The first step is therefore to understand what the problem is and which route is realistic. That usually requires a technical assessment by a qualified surveyor or architect, read alongside a legal review of the documents. For the wider framework on differences between a property and its records, see Planning Irregularities in Italian Property: What Buyers Must Check Before Making an Offer.
If nobody can say which procedure will be used, nobody can promise the result.
Who should define the required result?
The most common weakness in these contracts is vagueness. A clause stating that the seller will “regularise the property” or “deliver the property in compliance” leaves open what compliance means, which parts of the property are covered and who decides whether it has been achieved.
The buyer should insist that the contract defines:
- Which structure, room, terrace, pool or record is affected.
- Whether the goal is regularisation, correction of records, removal of works or a combination.
- Whether the regularised element will remain as it is, or will be modified.
- Which document will prove that the goal has been achieved.
- Whether the buyer’s technical adviser can review the result before completion.
If the outcome could involve removing a veranda or reducing a terrace, the buyer should know that in advance. The price agreed for a property with a glazed room may not be the right price for the same property without it.
Which document proves that regularisation is complete?
Completion should be proved by documents, not by statements. Depending on the route, the relevant evidence may include:
- An updated cadastral registration and floor plan consistent with the actual state.
- The final decision or confirmation issued by the municipality on the planning application.
- The formal closure of an amnesty file, with payment of all sums due.
- Evidence that removal or corrective works were completed and, where required, notified.
- Any related landscape or heritage authorisation where the property is protected.
A receipt showing that an application was filed is not proof of completion. Neither is a letter from the seller’s surveyor stating that the file is “in order”. The contract should list the documents the buyer must receive before the final deed.
Should the preliminary contract be signed before the process ends?
Often, yes. Waiting for a full regularisation before any commitment is not always practical, and a seller may not start costly procedures without a committed buyer. The question is how to sign safely.
The buyer’s options typically include:
- Signing a preliminary contract that makes the final deed conditional on regularisation being completed and documented.
- Keeping the deposit modest until the regularisation is achieved.
- Holding part of the price in escrow or retaining it until specific documents are delivered.
- Linking the completion date to the regularisation, with a longstop date after which the buyer may withdraw.
- Agreeing a price reduction if the outcome is partial, such as a structure that must be removed instead of regularised.
The right structure depends on the issue, the seller, the price and the timing. For an explanation of how a preliminary contract can protect a buyer, including registration in the property registers, read Preliminary Contract in Italy: Registration, Transcription and Protection Against Third Parties.
Where payment protection needs a formal structure, see Escrow Property Purchases.
What happens to the deposit if regularisation fails?
This is the question that matters most, and it is often the one left unanswered.
If the contract simply describes the payment as a caparra without addressing the regularisation, the buyer may face a dispute about whether the seller’s failure justifies withdrawal and recovery of the deposit, or whether the buyer must proceed anyway. The outcome can depend on how the clause was written.
A protective contract makes the answer explicit:
- If the required documents are not delivered by the agreed date, the buyer may withdraw.
- On withdrawal for that reason, the deposit is returned in full, or with any agreed additional amount.
- The seller bears the costs, fees and sanctions of the regularisation, unless otherwise agreed.
- Any extension of the deadline requires the buyer’s written consent.
For the difference between types of deposit and their consequences, read Caparra, Deposit or Advance Payment When Buying Property in Italy.
How should deadlines and extensions be controlled?
Regularisation procedures depend on public offices, technical work and sometimes third-party approvals. Delays are normal. Open-ended delays are not acceptable.
The contract should include a realistic target date, a clear longstop date and a rule on extensions. Automatic extensions “until the procedure is completed” leave the buyer bound indefinitely, with money exposed and no certainty about the outcome.
If the buyer is also selling another property, relocating or arranging finance, the regularisation timetable should be checked against those commitments before signing.
A practical example: a villa with an enclosed veranda and an old amnesty file
A Belgian buyer agrees to purchase a villa for €650,000. The seller discloses that a sea-facing veranda was enclosed without authorisation and that a rear extension relies on an amnesty application filed decades ago and never closed. The seller promises to regularise both before the deed and asks for a €65,000 deposit.
The buyer’s legal and technical review shows that the veranda may not be capable of regularisation because of landscape restrictions, while the amnesty file can probably be closed on payment of outstanding sums.
The preliminary contract is structured accordingly. The seller must close the amnesty file and deliver the final documents within six months. For the veranda, the seller must either obtain regularisation or restore the original open terrace, with a €40,000 price reduction if restoration is required. The deposit is reduced to €30,000 until the amnesty file is closed, and becomes refundable in full if the documents are not delivered by the longstop date.
The buyer still buys the villa. They simply pay for what will legally exist on the day of the deed.
How Govoni Law helps before you sign
Govoni Law assists foreign buyers throughout Italy. We act only for the buyer.
If you have been told that a problem will be fixed before completion, the Before You Sign Brief gives you a first written view of the risks, the missing documents and whether the promise can be relied on.
If the regularisation is the main open question, Light Due Diligence focuses on that issue and on the contract terms needed to protect you. For drafting and negotiating those terms, see Review and Negotiation of Purchase Offers and Preliminary Contracts.
For a serious commitment, Full Legal Due Diligence investigates title, planning and cadastral position, amnesty files, restrictions and contract terms, and coordinates with the surveyor or architect where technical input is needed.
Checklist: before relying on a seller’s regularisation promise
Before signing an offer or preliminary contract, make sure you have:
- Identified exactly which irregularity will be addressed.
- Obtained a technical view on which procedure is realistic.
- Understood whether the outcome is regularisation, correction or removal.
- Defined the documents that will prove completion.
- Agreed who pays costs, fees and sanctions.
- Set a target date, a longstop date and a rule on extensions.
- Linked the final deed to delivery of the documents.
- Kept the deposit proportionate to the risk.
- Considered escrow or price retention where appropriate.
- Agreed a price mechanism if the outcome is partial.
- Confirmed that the deposit is refundable if the condition fails.
Frequently asked questions
Can I buy a property in Italy that is not yet regularised?
Yes, but the risk should be addressed in the contract. The final deed can be made conditional on the regularisation being completed and documented, with a deadline and a clear remedy if it is not.
Is a filed application enough before the deed?
No. A filed application is not a completed regularisation. The buyer should receive the final decision or equivalent documents before completion, unless a different, deliberate risk allocation has been agreed.
Who pays for regularising the property?
It is a matter for negotiation, but the seller usually bears the costs and sanctions of irregularities that already exist. The contract should say so expressly.
What if the irregularity cannot be regularised?
The buyer may need the right to withdraw with a full refund, or to proceed with a price reduction if the seller removes or modifies the works. These options should be agreed before signing.
Does the notary refuse the deed if the property is irregular?
The notary requires certain declarations and cadastral conformity for the deed. This does not mean that every planning issue will be identified or resolved at that stage, or that the buyer’s plans for the property are protected.
Should I pay a full deposit while regularisation is pending?
Not necessarily. A reduced deposit, staged payments, escrow or price retention may better reflect the risk until the documents are delivered.
If a seller has promised to regularise a property you want to buy in Italy, contact Govoni Law before signing an offer or paying a deposit. Send the listing, the documents received and the draft contract, and we will tell you in writing how to protect your position.
A promise to fix the property is a good start. A contract that proves it is what protects you.